“Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose”
The more things change, the more they stay the same.
— Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr, from his 1849 journal Les Guêpes
This reflection captures a profound truth about the persistence of antisemitism. Despite rapid technological advancements and evolving social norms, the challenge of antisemitism remains as pressing as ever. Living in Jerusalem, a city steeped in history and conflict, I am reminded daily of this enduring struggle. The same prejudices that plagued past generations continue to influence our world today.
Navigating the Complexities of Criticism and Hate
Living in this historic city offers a unique vantage point. Every day, I witness the complexities of the Israel-Hamas conflict firsthand. A recent incident involving Israeli singer Yishai Rebo’s performance at Harvard brought these issues into sharp focus. His concert, intended to celebrate culture and unity, sparked protests from pro-Palestinian groups. While I understand the passion behind these protests, it was disheartening to see how swiftly they veered into antisemitic rhetoric.
Rabbi Yitzchak Schochet’s insight about how criticism of Israel can sometimes hide antisemitism resonates with my own experiences. It’s a delicate balance—distinguishing between valid critique and harmful bias is crucial. Conversations about the Israel-Hamas conflict often show how discussions can quickly turn from constructive dialogue to hostility.
Understanding Antisemitism’s Long Shadow
Antisemitism’s shadow is long and persistent. Growing up, I learned about the horrors faced by Jews throughout history—from the expulsions in Spain to the tragedies of the Holocaust. I often reflect on whether we are advancing or recycling the same old prejudices. The myths have evolved, but the animosity remains. Modern antisemitism, with its unfounded accusations and stereotypes, mirrors the ancient hatred that fueled past atrocities.
The Thin Line Between Activism and Antisemitism
In Jerusalem, where emotions run high, it’s easy to see how the line between activism and outright hatred can become dangerously blurred. Pro-Palestinian rhetoric, while often rooted in genuine concerns, sometimes includes misinformation that exacerbates tensions and fosters intolerance. This reality underscores the importance of carefully scrutinizing sources and questioning narratives that might perpetuate biases.
Nonie Darwish’s story offers a powerful illustration of how deeply held beliefs can be challenged and transformed. Growing up in Cairo and Gaza with strong anti-Israel sentiments, Darwish’s journey toward rejecting these views demonstrates that change is possible, even when it seems improbable. Her personal transformation and her daughter, Shireen Said’s efforts in promoting reconciliation highlight the profound impact of confronting and overcoming entrenched biases.
The Battle of College Campuses
The rise of antisemitism on college campuses, often disguised as pro-Palestinian activism, is particularly alarming. Universities, which should be bastions of learning and growth, are increasingly becoming sites of hostility. The video, The Jewish Voices on Campus, underscores the need for unity among different faiths and communities to combat radical ideologies.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
Statistics from the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) reflect a troubling rise in antisemitic incidents, especially during Middle Eastern conflicts. These numbers are not just statistics—they represent real pain and suffering.
Finding Guidance in Sacred Texts
During these challenging times, I seek guidance and comfort in sacred texts. Judith Klitzner’s work, “In Your Brother’s Blood is Crying: Biblical Origins of Our Divided Society,” provides deep insights. Her examination of biblical conflicts among ‘siblings’ resonates with today’s challenges. Klitzner’s reflections bridge ancient wisdom with contemporary struggles, offering valuable perspectives for navigating our modern world.
A Path Forward: Combating Antisemitism
Addressing antisemitism requires a thoughtful approach:
- Education: Advocate for accurate representations of Jewish history and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Knowledge can dispel myths and reduce prejudice.
- Interfaith Dialogue: Engage in meaningful conversations with people of different faiths to build mutual understanding and respect. Dialogue fosters a more harmonious society.
- Supporting Organizations: Support groups like the ADL that work tirelessly against antisemitism and protect our communities.
My journey has deepened my understanding of the complexities of antisemitism and reinforced my commitment to fighting it with both knowledge and empathy.
What steps can you take in your community to challenge and combat antisemitism? I invite you to reflect on this question and consider how you might contribute to fostering understanding and tolerance in your daily interactions. We can work towards a more compassionate world by taking these steps and embracing diverse perspectives.
Footnotes:
- Judith Klitzner, “Your Brother’s Blood is Calling Out,” Ikar, YouTube, April 29, 2023, based on Genesis 37:3-4 and Genesis 45:3-15.
- The Holy Bible: The Jewish Publication Society Tanakh Translation. Jewish Publication Society, 1999. Genesis 37:3-4: “And Israel loved Joseph more than all his sons, because he was a son of his old age; and he made him a fine woolen coat. And his brothers saw that their father loved him more than all his brothers, so they hated him.”
- The Holy Bible: The Jewish Publication Society Tanakh Translation. Jewish Publication Society, 1999. Genesis 45:3-9: “And Joseph said to his brothers, ‘I am Joseph. Is my father still alive?’ … God sent me before you to make for you a remnant in the land, and to preserve [it] for you for a great deliverance. Hasten and go up to my father, and say to him, ‘God has made me a lord over all the Egyptians.’”