A well-known maxim states, “You can fool some of the people some of the time, but you can’t fool all of the people all of the time.” This sentiment applies to discerning “truth from misinformation” in our media-saturated world.

Francisco Gil-White‘s research (1) highlights a troubling reality: many people form their views not from direct experience but from the narratives crafted by the media. This phenomenon was starkly evident in the antisemitic propaganda about Jews disseminated by mainstream German, American, and other Western media sources in the first part of the twentieth century. Before WWII, media outlets demonized Jews in print (2) and on the radio, shaping public perception. These falsified stories and exaggerated portrayals aimed to make Jews appear fearful and loathsome to the general public, reminiscent of the demonization of Jews in ancient texts like the book of Exodus (1:1-16). (3)

In hindsight, this raises an essential question: If Jews were perceived as so influential and powerful, how were European powers able to systematically persecute and murder six million of them between 1941 and 1945 without significant opposition from major world powers? The historical context reveals a stark contradiction.

Media Misinformation

Today, questions persist about the portrayal of Israel in contemporary media. Is Israel committing genocide in Gaza? Is there a humanitarian crisis? How many civilians have perished? The challenge lies in discerning reliable sources amid the proliferation of conflicting narratives. Can mainstream media outlets like CNN, CBC, BBC, PRX, and MSNBC provide an unbiased depiction of the Israel-Hamas conflict? Should information from social media, internet sources, and NGOs be trusted? What about the reliability of Wikipedia?

Mainstream Media

Several major media outlets, such as CNN, CBC, The New York Times, and The Washington Post, have been accused of bias in their reporting on Israel, often favouring progressive left-wing ideologies. Recent revelations, including the CBC whistleblower reports and discussions in Commentary Magazine’s podcast “Stopping the Presses” (released June 7, 2024), have highlighted these long-standing biases and efforts towards reform in major American media. (4)

NGO Bias

Human rights and humanitarian organizations such as Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Doctors Without Borders, among others, have been criticized for biased reporting on Israel. NGO Monitor and UNWatch consistently document these biases. A recent report from NGO Monitor accused many NGOs of downplaying Hamas atrocities and framing them as resistance against Israeli policies labelled as “apartheid” and “oppression,” contributing to global antisemitism and the demonization of Israel. (5)

Influence of Social Media: Bots and AI

Social media platforms such as Twitter and Facebook significantly impact public opinion and can amplify misinformation. Biased narratives are quickly spread and reinforced by algorithms that create echo chambers, making distinguishing between fact and fiction challenging. In addition, foreign-influenced bots pose a severe threat, exacerbating the issue.

For example, Taiwan has actively taken steps to counter Chinese bots on its social media platforms and has shared its strategies with Israel. An article by Jeremy Bob in the Jerusalem Post titled “How Israel Can Defend Itself from Iran Using Taiwan’s Anti-China Playbook” explores how Israel could adopt Taiwan’s tactics to combat disinformation campaigns from Iran and other adversaries. It is crucial for all Western governments to urgently address the issue of foreign influence on the internet.

Wikipedia

While Wikipedia is a popular information source, it has been criticized for bias against Israel. Investigative journalist Aaron Bandler detailed instances where Wikipedia editors manipulated content to favour anti-Israel narratives (6).

Student Campus Protests and Hidden Agendas

University campuses often witness pro-Palestinian protests organized by groups like Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) and Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP). These movements, supported by organizations like the US Campaign for Palestinian Rights (USCPR), employ rhetoric accusing Israel of “apartheid,” “ethnic cleansing,” and “genocide,” narratives challenged by investigative bodies like ISGAP and SPME. Transparency about funding sources, such as USCPR’s substantial support from the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, underscores the complexity and controversy surrounding these campaigns. (7)

The Importance of Media Integrity in Civil Democratic Societies

The media serves as a pivotal force in shaping public opinion and influencing the democratic process. However, its integrity and reliability are constantly under threat, particularly evident in authoritarian regimes like China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea. These regimes often manipulate the media to destabilize democratic institutions, underscoring the crucial need for global media literacy and accountability to safeguard democratic freedoms.

The conflict in Ukraine provides a stark example of how media can be used to advance geopolitical agendas. Russia’s annexation of Crimea and ongoing tensions along the Russia-Ukraine border illustrate President Putin’s ambitions for territorial expansion through illicit means. Such actions not only violate international norms but also challenge the sovereignty of democratic nations.

Iran’s ambitions in the Middle East present another critical issue. With its stated goal of regional dominance and threats against Israel, Iran poses a significant threat not only to regional stability but also to global security. The situation in Israel and Gaza, often framed as a struggle for territorial and human rights, extends beyond local concerns. It represents a broader threat aimed at the very existence of Israel and its people, with potential ramifications reaching countries across the globe, including the US, Canada, Europe, and England.

Media Watchdog

It is crucial to establish mechanisms that ensure accountability in the media and uphold responsible journalism. One notable organization, Honest Reporting, has been diligently monitoring and documenting media bias related to Israel for many years. They provide daily briefings and maintain a dedicated page for Canadian media, accessible to anyone who wishes to stay informed.

Access to reliable information is fundamental for the integrity of democratic societies. Historical events, such as Hitler’s exploitation of democratic processes to seize power and establish a dictatorship, underscore the dangers posed by misinformation and public indifference.

Tools for Critical Media Consumption

Media literacy equips individuals to discern misinformation and biased agendas. Here are some tips to spot and avoid misinformation:

• Recognize confirmation bias by seeking out diverse opinions and perspectives. Don’t stick to only one source for news.
• Investigate the author and reporter’s backgrounds and the ideological bias of the newsgathering institution to understand their perspectives.
• Beware of sensationalist language like “genocide” and “war crimes” and focus on factual content from reliable sources.
• Continuously improve media literacy skills to adapt to evolving misinformation tactics.

Trusted Sources for Accurate News

I’ve compiled trusted news sources I’ve relied on over the years.

• Associated Press (AP), has been the go-to aggregator of news for mainstream media exposed as biased towards Israel: Have you heard of WIN World Israel News? It serves a similar function by providing aggregated news on Israel but includes more Jewish and Israeli sources.
• Consider the Israeli English-language TV channel I-24 and TOI – Times of Israel for a direct feed from Israel.
• Commentators like Dennis Prager, Douglas Murray, Melanie Phillips, Brigitte Gabriel, Francisco Gil-White, and Hassan Youssef are well-informed and reliable sources regarding the Middle East. I have followed them for years.

Regarding NGOs and citizen organizations, these groups are known for their insightful perspectives:

• Defense of Democracies
• Hoover Institute
• EMET
• ISGAP – I have recorded many of ISGAP’s lectures, which are available on my YouTube channel.
• CIJR
• IDSF

As history reminds us, misinformation and bias have profound consequences. Upholding truth and justice requires vigilance against media manipulation to ensure democratic integrity and informed public discourse.

---

FOOTNOTEs:

1. Gil-White, Francisco. “Geopolitical and Historic Insights on Jews, Israel, and the Battle Against Antisemitism.” Ask Abigail Productions, www.askabigailproductions.com/francisco-gil-white-geopolitical-and-historic-insights-on-jews-israel-and-the-battle-against-antisemitism.
2. “Der Stürmer (Antisemitic Newspaper).” Montreal Holocaust Museum, www.museeholocauste.ca/en/objects/der-sturmer-antisemitic-newspaper.
3. Klitzner, Judith. Torah from Israel with Judy Klitsner. YouTube, https://youtube.com.
   In Genesis, Joseph’s brothers, angered by their father’s favoritism toward him and Joseph’s dreams of dominance, sell him into slavery. Joseph rises to power in Egypt and later forgives his brothers, inviting them to settle there during a famine. In Exodus, the descendants of Jacob, now called Israelites, face oppression in Egypt under a new Pharaoh who fears their numbers. He imposes harsh labor and orders the killing of Hebrew male infants (Exodus 1:1-17).
4. Kinsella, Warren. “Covert internal group oversees CBC’s coverage of Israel.” Toronto Sun, Toronto Sun, 27 Nov. 2020, torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/kinsella-covert-internal-group-oversees-cbcs-coverage-of-israel.
5. NGO Monitor. “Blaming the Victim: NGOs, the Apartheid Libel, and the Hamas Massacre.” NGO Monitor, www.ngo-monitor.org/reports/blaming-the-victim-ngos-the-apartheid-libel-and-the-hamas-massacre.
6. “7 Tactics Wikipedia Editors Used to Spread Anti-Israel Bias Since Oct. 7.” Jewish Journal, 7 Oct. 2021, https://jewishjournal.com/cover_story/371545/7-tactics-wikipedia-editors-used-to-spread-anti-israel-bias-since-oct-7.
7. NGO Monitor. “NGO Network Orchestrating Antisemitic Incitement on American Campuses.” NGO Monitor, www.ngo-monitor.org/reports/ngo-network-orchestrating-antisemitic-incitement-on-american-campuses.