The Rising Tide of Antisemitism in Canada: A Concern for Our Shared Values

Canada is often celebrated as a beacon of diversity and acceptance, where different cultures, religions, and identities come together. However, recent events have raised troubling concerns about a rise in antisemitism and radical ideologies that may threaten our democratic values.

A Crisis That Hits Home

The news surrounding Birju Dattani, the former Chief Commissioner of the Canadian Human Rights Commission, underscores that antisemitism is not just a distant issue; it affects us all. Dattani’s antisemitic remarks and justification of terrorism are alarming, particularly coming from someone in such an influential role. Following public outcry, his demotion by Justice Minister Arif Virani highlights a need for accountability in our institutions. Yet, it prompts important questions about how someone with such views rose to a prominent position in the first place.

As a member of the Jewish community, I, too, feel uneasy. This situation reflects broader issues within our systems and raises concerns about aligning our values with our actions.

A Broader Threat

Recent incidents, such as the arrest of a father and son in the Greater Toronto Area for allegedly planning terror attacks inspired by ISIS, add to these concerns. This raises serious questions about our vetting processes and the potential for violence rooted in extremist ideologies. If a global figure like Taylor Swift isn’t safe due to threats, it makes us reflect on the safety of our own communities. Radical ideologies can transcend borders, impacting even the most stable societies.

Antisemitism: A Warning Sign

Antisemitism is often described as a “canary in the coal mine” for societal health. When hatred against Jews rises, it signals deeper societal issues that can affect everyone. In Canada, the increase in antisemitism indicates that extremist ideologies threaten our shared values. For many, including myself, this rise feels like a betrayal of the inclusive society Canada aims to embody.

Why We Need to Act

Fighting antisemitism is crucial not only for the Jewish community but for the integrity of our entire society. Allowing hatred and bigotry to go unchecked can undermine the very foundation of our democratic values.

To address these issues, we can:

  • Educate and Advocate: Raise awareness about antisemitism and radical ideologies through discussions and workshops in schools, workplaces, and communities.
  • Speak Out: Challenge antisemitic rhetoric and extremist ideas when encountered, as every voice matters in combating hate.
  • Report Hate Crimes: Reporting incidents of hate is essential to addressing and reducing their occurrence.
  • Support Victims: Offer emotional support to victims, attend solidarity events, and contribute to relevant causes.
  • Build Community: Strengthen ties with interfaith and intercultural groups to collectively counter hate.
  • Support Organizations: Organizations like the Canadian Antisemitism Education Foundation (CAEF) and the Simon Wiesenthal Center play vital roles and need our support.
  • Push for Change: Advocate for policies that combat extremism and protect our shared values.

As Sam Harris recently emphasized, “Our democracy and the rule of law are only as strong as our commitment to defending them against all forms of hatred and extremism.”

A Personal Call to Action

I write this as a concerned citizen who cares deeply about the future of our country. We must all engage in the fight against antisemitism and radicalism. It’s a fight for our shared values and the society we wish to build. This is a battle we cannot afford to lose.

 

Confronting Antisemitism in Canada and Beyond

The events of October 7 in Israel are etched in my memory. I was in Jerusalem when Hamas, the governing authority in Gaza, launched an attack that breached the border and plunged nearby communities into chaos. The violence was horrific, resulting in the abduction of over 230 hostages—men, women, and children of all ages. Amid this turmoil, I witnessed the remarkable resilience of ordinary Israeli citizens and local police who bravely confronted the attackers, saving lives before the IDF (Israeli Defense Forces) arrived. Their courage was a powerful reminder of the strength of the human spirit in the face of unimaginable adversity.

Upon my return to Canada, I attended a conference in Ottawa organized by the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA) on October 16 and 17. Scheduled initially long before the outbreak of war, the gathering took on new urgency in light of recent events. With over 1,500 attendees—including students, professionals, law enforcement officers, and educators—the conference focused on the alarming resurgence of antisemitism in Canada, particularly as it spreads through social media. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Opposition Leader Pierre Poilievre emphasized that fighting antisemitism is not just a Jewish issue; it’s a Canadian one that affects us all.

The personal stories shared during the conference were impactful. One teacher from the Ottawa Public School System recounted the bullying faced by young Jewish students, underscoring that antisemitism is not a distant problem; it’s occurring right here in our communities. The conference’s message was clear: “Silence is collusion.” We cannot allow antisemitism to spread unchecked.

After hearing these powerful dialogues, I had the opportunity to meet with Members of Parliament, including Sherry Romanado and Brad Redekopp. These formalities and genuine, open exchanges highlighted the potential for real, collaborative action.

However, the environment remains complex. As we exited the conference hall, we encountered a Palestinian protest outside. This moment highlighted the need for dialogue and understanding between communities, reminding us that the paths to peace and justice intersect unexpectedly.

Resilience and Unity: How the Jewish Community Responds

While the conference underscored the urgent need for action in Canada, it also highlighted the enduring resilience of the Jewish people, both in Israel and the diaspora. Despite centuries of exile, Jewish communities worldwide have stood together through adversity, caring for the vulnerable among us. In Montreal, the Federation-CJA continues this tradition, working tirelessly to support those in need, particularly during times of crisis. This year’s fundraising campaign is particularly urgent, focusing on raising funds for the war effort in Israel.

In 2020, Ishai Ribo captured this sentiment in his rendition of “Vehi She’amda,” reminding us that despite those who have sought to harm us, we have always endured. Our traditions, rooted in Torah study and Jewish values, anchor us through good times and bad. This dedication to Jewish practice unites us in our efforts to support Israel, facing existential threats—whether against Hamas, Hezbollah, Iran, or the growing threats of antisemitism in our backyards.

 

Antisemitism is not a new phenomenon; it’s a persistent thread woven throughout history. As we are reminded during Passover, “Through the ages, many have risen to destroy us. But the Holy One, Blessed Be He, always saves us from their hand!” This message resonates deeply, especially during crises.

Moving Forward with Hope and Action

In today’s world, with its constant barrage of conflict and suffering, it’s easy to feel helpless. Yet, we must remember that we all have the power to make a difference. Whether standing up against injustice or supporting someone in need, our actions, however small, matter. Moments of kindness can transform situations, reminding us of our shared humanity and responsibility to improve the world for everyone.

When we come together as a community, our impact is amplified. Despite our differences, we share a common goal: to create a world where everyone can live free from persecution. Our tradition teaches us to pray for “the lion to lie down with the lamb,” envisioning a time of peace where the strong and weak coexist harmoniously. This hope extends beyond the Jewish community; it is a vision for everyone.

As we fervently pray for the swift and safe return of the hostages taken by Hamas on October 7—hashtag ba’agala uvizman karat—let us strive for a future where our collective efforts, resilience, and unity lead to a world free from hatred and conflict.

 

The Journey of Rabbi Chaim Steinmetz

Rabbi Chaim Steinmetz’s transition from his role as the spiritual leader of Congregation Tifereth Beth David Jerusalem (TBDJ) in Montreal to his current position at Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun (KJ) on Manhattan’s Upper East Side marks a significant chapter in his personal and spiritual journey. This move reflects a change in location and an evolution in his mission to inspire and guide his community.

Rabbi Steinmetz has delivered powerful sermons that resonate deeply with his audience throughout his tenure at both congregations. His addresses cover many topics that foster self-awareness, resilience, and a deeper understanding of our Jewish heritage. For instance, in “When a Fossil Comes to Life,” he artfully connects historical events to personal growth, urging us to embrace change and transformation. His discourse on “Never Underestimate Hatred” serves as a timely reminder of the importance of confronting prejudice. At the same time, “Yizkor and Yom HaShoah: Between Past and Present” draws vital connections between memory and communal responsibility.

As someone who has had the privilege of archiving his teachings, I’ve witnessed firsthand the profound wisdom in his words. I have documented his six-minute talks over the years, which concisely and engagingly encapsulate his insights. Some of these talks include:

Rabbi Steinmetz’s transition from TBDJ to KJ has been marked by profound insights and impactful discourses that have inspired his community. His commitment to guiding others through Jewish history and contemporary challenges reflects a deep dedication to meaningful dialogue.

The diverse topics he addresses have resonated with many individuals. Have you felt the impact of Rabbi Steinmetz’s teachings? They serve as a beacon of hope, embodying a legacy of compassion and truth. His teachings leave a lasting impression, encouraging appreciation and reflection within the community. Rabbi Steinmetz’s journey illustrates how the power of words can inspire change and strengthen our connection to faith and community.